HIFEM Chair Therapy vs Pelvic Floor Surgery for Incontinence

HIFEM chair therapy uses a strong magnetic field to make the pelvic floor muscles contract while you sit fully clothed, whereas pelvic floor surgery physically restores support under the urethra or vagina. The chair is non-invasive with no downtime but has limited, mostly short-term evidence; surgery is more invasive but has much stronger, longer-lasting results for moderate to severe stress incontinence.
What is HIFEM chair therapy?
HIFEM stands for high-intensity focused electromagnetic technology. In this treatment, you sit on a chair-like device that generates a pulsing magnetic field. The field induces electrical currents in the nerves of the pelvic floor, causing rapid, strong muscle contractions, often thousands in a single session. The aim is to strengthen and re-educate the pelvic floor muscles without the need for you to contract them voluntarily.
A typical course involves around six to eight sessions, each lasting about 30 minutes, given once or twice a week. No undressing, probes or anesthesia are needed. Most women feel tingling and strong muscle tightening during the session, and they return to normal activities immediately.
Magnetic stimulation is not new; it has been studied for incontinence since the late 1990s. Newer devices deliver higher intensities and are marketed more widely.
What does pelvic floor surgery for incontinence involve?
Surgery for stress incontinence aims to provide lasting mechanical support. The main options are:
- Mid-urethral sling: a narrow synthetic tape placed under the urethra, usually as day surgery.
- Burch colposuspension: stitches that lift the tissue near the bladder neck, performed laparoscopically or through an abdominal incision.
- Autologous fascial sling: a strip of your own tissue placed under the bladder neck, often for severe or recurrent cases.
- Prolapse repair: when incontinence is linked to pelvic organ prolapse, correcting the prolapse may also be needed.
Surgery cannot strengthen muscles; it replaces lost structural support. Chair therapy, in contrast, works only on muscle and cannot repair torn ligaments or fascia.
HIFEM chair therapy vs surgery: side-by-side comparison
These points summarize the general differences.
HIFEM chair therapy
- Mechanism: magnetically induced pelvic floor muscle contractions
- Invasiveness: none; fully clothed
- Sessions: a course of several sessions, with maintenance often suggested
- Downtime: none
- Evidence: small studies, few rigorous sham-controlled trials, mostly short follow-up
- Best possible role: mild stress or mixed incontinence; women unable to perform pelvic floor exercises effectively
- Risks: generally minor, such as temporary muscle soreness; not suitable with metal implants near the pelvis, pacemakers or during pregnancy
Pelvic floor surgery
- Mechanism: structural support under the urethra or for prolapse
- Invasiveness: incisions and anesthesia
- Sessions: usually a single operation
- Downtime: about two weeks for slings to six weeks for larger operations
- Evidence: large randomized trials with long-term data
- Best role: moderate to severe stress incontinence not helped by conservative care
- Risks: voiding difficulty, new urgency, pain, infection, mesh complications with synthetic slings
What does the evidence say about magnetic chair therapy?
Some studies have reported improvements in leakage and quality of life after a course of magnetic stimulation, particularly in women with mild stress incontinence. However, many of these studies are small, lack a sham control group or follow women for only a few months. Results from controlled trials have been mixed, and it remains unclear how long any benefit lasts once sessions stop. Some magnetic stimulation devices have been cleared by the US FDA for treating urinary incontinence, but clearance means a device is considered substantially similar to existing devices, not that it has been proven superior to standard care. In the UK, NICE guidance on urinary incontinence in women has advised against offering magnetic stimulation outside of research, reflecting the uncertain evidence. Professional opinion may change as better-quality trials are published.
By contrast, supervised pelvic floor muscle training has strong evidence. A Cochrane review found that women who completed training were substantially more likely to report cure or improvement than untreated women. Magnetic chair therapy has not been shown to outperform well-taught, consistently practiced exercises.
What does the evidence say about surgery?
Continence surgery has decades of research. Mid-urethral slings and colposuspension show high rates of cure or major improvement, with lasting benefit for many women at five years and beyond. The trade-off is surgical risk. These include the risks of anesthesia, difficulty emptying the bladder, new urgency symptoms and, with synthetic slings, the possibility of mesh exposure or chronic pain. Careful patient selection and an experienced surgeon reduce, but cannot eliminate, these risks.
Who might consider each option?
Chair therapy may be worth discussing if you:
- Have mild stress or mixed incontinence
- Struggle to identify or contract your pelvic floor muscles despite guidance
- Want a non-invasive option and accept uncertain, possibly temporary results
- Are not ready for surgery or have health conditions that make surgery riskier
Surgery may be more appropriate if you:
- Have moderate to severe stress incontinence that limits daily life
- Have completed supervised pelvic floor training without enough improvement
- Have significant pelvic organ prolapse contributing to symptoms
- Want a single treatment with well-documented long-term outcomes
Which should you choose?
A stepwise approach is usually best:
- Get an accurate diagnosis of the type of incontinence, including a bladder diary and pelvic examination.
- Start supervised pelvic floor muscle training with a pelvic health physiotherapist for at least three months.
- Use biofeedback or electrical stimulation if you cannot contract the muscles effectively; magnetic chair therapy may be considered at this stage.
- Reassess symptoms; if leakage remains bothersome, discuss surgical options.
- Choose surgery based on your type of incontinence, anatomy, preferences about mesh and your surgeon's experience.
When thinking about value, remember that a chair course often needs repeating, whereas surgery is usually a one-time procedure with its own risks. Ask any provider what results they expect for someone with your symptoms, how long benefits typically last and what the plan is if treatment does not help.
Frequently asked questions
Does HIFEM chair therapy work for stress incontinence?
It may help some women with mild stress incontinence, but the evidence is limited and long-term data are lacking. It has not been shown to be more effective than supervised pelvic floor exercises or as effective as surgery.
How long do chair therapy results last?
This is uncertain. Benefits reported in studies often decline over months after treatment ends, and many providers recommend periodic maintenance sessions.
Who should not use a magnetic chair?
Women who are pregnant, have a pacemaker or other implanted electronic devices, or have metal implants in or near the pelvis are usually advised not to use it. Your provider should screen you before treatment.
Can I try chair therapy before deciding on surgery?
Yes, many women try conservative options first. Trying a chair course does not prevent later surgery, but it should not delay proper assessment if symptoms are severe.
References
- Dumoulin C, Cacciari LP, Hay-Smith EJC. Pelvic floor muscle training versus no treatment, or inactive control treatments, for urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2018.
- Ford AA, et al. Mid-urethral sling operations for stress urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017.
- American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Practice Bulletin No. 155: Urinary Incontinence in Women. Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2015.
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Urinary incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse in women: management (NG123), 2019.
This article is for general education and does not replace an examination by a qualified gynecologist. Individual results vary, and every procedure carries risks.









