Laser Treatment vs Surgery for Urinary Incontinence

Vaginal laser is a low-downtime office treatment that may modestly improve mild stress incontinence for a limited time, while surgery such as a mid-urethral sling or colposuspension has far stronger evidence and longer-lasting results. Laser is still considered investigational for incontinence by major organizations, so surgery remains the standard for moderate to severe stress leakage.
How does vaginal laser treatment for incontinence work?
Vaginal laser devices, mainly erbium (Er:YAG) and fractional carbon dioxide (CO2) lasers, deliver controlled heat to the front wall of the vagina beneath the urethra. The idea is that the heat triggers a healing response, stimulating new collagen and thickening the tissue that supports the urethra and bladder neck.
A typical course involves two or three sessions about a month apart, each taking around 15 to 30 minutes, with little or no anesthesia. Most women return to normal activities the same day, though sexual intercourse is often avoided for several days afterwards.
Laser does not repair a torn ligament or replace weakened sphincter muscle. Its theoretical benefit is limited to improving the quality and firmness of the vaginal wall, which may explain why results are reported mainly in mild stress incontinence.
What surgical options exist for stress incontinence?
Surgery aims to create lasting support under the urethra. The main operations are:
- Mid-urethral sling: a narrow synthetic tape placed under the urethra through a small vaginal incision. It is the most studied continence operation.
- Burch colposuspension: stitches lift tissue near the bladder neck and attach it behind the pubic bone, done through an abdominal incision or laparoscopically.
- Autologous fascial sling: a strip of the woman's own tissue placed under the bladder neck, often used for severe or recurrent leakage.
- Urethral bulking injections: a less invasive procedure that adds volume around the urethra, sometimes grouped with surgery.
Each operation has extensive published data, including randomized trials and long-term follow-up.
Laser vs surgery: side-by-side comparison
The following points summarize general differences.
Vaginal laser
- Setting: outpatient office procedure
- Anesthesia: usually none or topical
- Downtime: minimal; normal activity often the same day
- Number of sessions: typically two or three, with maintenance sessions often suggested
- Evidence: mainly small or short-term studies; few high-quality randomized trials, with mixed results
- Best possible role: mild stress incontinence in women who want to avoid or delay surgery
- Risks: vaginal discharge, temporary discomfort, and rare reports of burns, scarring or chronic pain
Surgery
- Setting: operating room, often day surgery for slings
- Anesthesia: general, spinal or local with sedation
- Downtime: from about two weeks for slings to six weeks for open procedures
- Number of procedures: usually one
- Evidence: large randomized trials and long-term data, especially for slings
- Best role: moderate to severe stress incontinence, or mild cases not helped by conservative care
- Risks: bladder emptying difficulty, pain, infection, mesh complications with slings, new urgency
What does the evidence say about laser for incontinence?
Early studies, many of them uncontrolled and funded by device manufacturers, reported improvement in leakage for some women. Since then, a small number of randomized sham-controlled trials have produced mixed results, with some finding little difference compared with a sham procedure. The benefit, where it appears, seems to fade over months, prompting repeat sessions.
In 2018, the US FDA issued a safety communication warning against marketing energy-based devices for "vaginal rejuvenation" and related conditions, including urinary incontinence, noting that the safety and effectiveness of these devices for such uses had not been established. Professional consensus documents since then, including a joint statement from the International Continence Society and the International Society for the Study of Vulvovaginal Disease, have concluded that laser should not be used routinely for stress incontinence outside of well-designed clinical research.
This does not mean laser never helps. It means the evidence is not yet strong enough to recommend it over established options.
What does the evidence say about surgery?
Surgery has decades of data. Mid-urethral slings show high rates of cure or major improvement in randomized trials, with continued benefit for many women at five years and beyond. Burch colposuspension and fascial slings also show durable results. The trade-off is a higher risk of operative complications than with an office procedure, including the specific concerns linked to synthetic mesh. Discussing these risks honestly is an essential part of consent.
Surgical outcomes also depend on the surgeon. Results reported in trials come largely from experienced teams, so it is reasonable to ask how often your surgeon performs the operation, how complications are followed up, and what would happen if leakage returned. A good surgeon will also explain the option of not having surgery at all.
Who might consider laser, and who should consider surgery?
Laser may be discussed, ideally within a research setting or with clear understanding of the uncertain evidence, by women who:
- Have mild stress incontinence that persists after supervised pelvic floor muscle training
- Strongly prefer to avoid surgery or are not yet ready for it
- Accept that results may be modest, temporary and not guaranteed
Surgery is usually more appropriate for women who:
- Have moderate to severe stress incontinence that affects daily life
- Have not improved enough with pelvic floor training
- Want a single procedure with well-documented long-term outcomes
Which should you choose?
For most women, the recommended path starts with conservative care and moves to surgery if needed:
- Confirm the type of incontinence with a history, bladder diary and examination.
- Complete at least three months of supervised pelvic floor muscle training.
- Address weight, constipation, chronic cough and fluid habits.
- Consider a vaginal support device if you want a non-surgical option.
- Discuss surgery, comparing slings, colposuspension and fascial slings, if leakage remains bothersome.
- If you are considering laser, ask about the specific evidence, the number of sessions, how long results last and what happens if it does not work.
Laser is a reasonable conversation, but it should not replace an accurate diagnosis or delay effective treatment for significant incontinence.
Frequently asked questions
Is vaginal laser approved for treating incontinence?
Laser devices are cleared for general medical uses, such as cutting or removing tissue, but in the US they are not specifically cleared for treating urinary incontinence. The FDA warned in 2018 about marketing them for this purpose.
How long do laser results last?
Studies that report benefit suggest it often lasts months rather than years, and repeat sessions are commonly offered. Long-term evidence is limited.
Is laser safer than surgery?
Laser has fewer serious risks per session, but burns, scarring and pain have been reported. Because its effectiveness is less certain, the overall balance of benefit and risk is not as well established as for surgery.
Can laser treat urge incontinence?
There is no good evidence that laser treats urge incontinence or overactive bladder. Those conditions are managed with bladder training, medicines and nerve-targeted therapies.
References
- US Food and Drug Administration. FDA warns against use of energy-based devices to perform vaginal "rejuvenation" or vaginal cosmetic procedures: FDA Safety Communication, 2018.
- Preti M, et al. The clinical role of LASER for vulvar and vaginal treatments in gynecology and female urology: an ICS/ISSVD best practice consensus document. Neurourology and Urodynamics, 2019.
- Ford AA, et al. Mid-urethral sling operations for stress urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017.
- American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Practice Bulletin No. 155: Urinary Incontinence in Women. Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2015.
This article is for general education and does not replace an examination by a qualified gynecologist. Individual results vary, and every procedure carries risks.









