Manchester Repair vs Hysteropexy

Manchester repair and hysteropexy are both operations that treat uterine prolapse while keeping the uterus, but they work differently. The Manchester repair shortens and reattaches the supporting ligaments through the vagina and usually removes part of the cervix. Hysteropexy suspends the uterus to a strong ligament or bone, either vaginally or laparoscopically, without removing the cervix.
Why consider keeping the uterus during prolapse surgery?
For many decades, removing the uterus (vaginal hysterectomy) was the default first step when the uterus had dropped. Today, more women ask whether the uterus can stay, and gynecologic surgeons increasingly agree that hysterectomy is not always necessary to fix apical prolapse. The uterus itself is usually healthy; the problem is that its supports, mainly the uterosacral and cardinal ligaments, have stretched or torn.
Common reasons women prefer a uterus-sparing operation include:
- A wish to avoid a larger operation or a longer recovery
- Personal, cultural or body-image reasons for keeping the uterus
- Concern about effects on sexual function, although evidence on this point is mixed
- Wanting to keep future pregnancy possible, though pregnancy after prolapse surgery carries a real risk of recurrence and is usually discussed carefully
Uterine preservation is not suitable for everyone. Abnormal bleeding, fibroids, a thickened endometrium, an abnormal cervical screening history or a high inherited cancer risk may make hysterectomy the safer choice.
What is the Manchester repair?
The Manchester repair, also called the Manchester–Fothergill operation, is a vaginal procedure first described in the late nineteenth century. It is designed mainly for women whose cervix is elongated, meaning the cervix has stretched downward so that the lowest point of the prolapse is the cervix rather than the whole uterus.
In general, the surgeon removes a portion of the elongated cervix (cervical amputation), then shortens the cardinal ligaments and stitches them to the front of the remaining cervix. This tightens the support at the top of the vagina. A front wall repair is often done at the same time if the bladder has also dropped.
The operation is done entirely through the vagina, so there are no abdominal cuts. It has seen renewed interest in Europe since mesh restrictions, and several comparative studies suggest outcomes that are at least similar to vaginal hysterectomy for suitable patients.
What is hysteropexy?
Hysteropexy means fixing the uterus back into its normal position. Instead of shortening the ligaments around the cervix, the surgeon anchors the cervix or lower uterus to a strong structure. The main types are:
- Sacrospinous hysteropexy: a vaginal operation in which the cervix is stitched to the sacrospinous ligament in the pelvis, usually on one side.
- Uterosacral hysteropexy: the uterosacral ligaments are shortened and reattached, either vaginally or laparoscopically.
- Sacrohysteropexy: a laparoscopic or robotic operation that uses a strip of synthetic mesh to attach the uterus to the front of the sacrum (tailbone). This is an abdominal mesh procedure, which regulators treat differently from transvaginal mesh.
Each technique has its own profile of benefits and risks, so "hysteropexy" is really a family of operations rather than a single procedure.
Manchester repair vs hysteropexy: side-by-side comparison
The points below summarize typical differences. Your surgeon's experience and your own anatomy can change the balance.
Manchester repair
- Approach: vaginal only, no abdominal incisions
- Best suited to: an elongated cervix with fairly good upper uterine support
- Cervix: partly removed
- Mesh: none; uses your own tissue
- Typical stay: short, often one night or day-case in some centers
- Specific risks: cervical narrowing (stenosis), possible effects on future pregnancy, bleeding
Hysteropexy
- Approach: vaginal (sacrospinous, uterosacral) or laparoscopic (uterosacral, sacrohysteropexy)
- Best suited to: uterine descent without major cervical elongation
- Cervix: kept intact
- Mesh: none for vaginal and uterosacral types; mesh for sacrohysteropexy
- Typical stay: short for vaginal routes; may be one to two nights for laparoscopic routes
- Specific risks: buttock or leg pain after sacrospinous fixation, mesh exposure after sacrohysteropexy, front wall recurrence
How do recovery and results compare?
Recovery after either operation follows a similar pattern because both are pelvic floor repairs that need time to heal. Most women go home within one or two days. A typical recovery looks like this:
- First week: rest at home, short walks, pain relief and attention to soft bowel movements.
- Weeks two to four: gradual return to light daily activities and desk work for many women.
- Weeks four to six: follow-up examination to check healing; sexual activity is often resumed after this visit if healing is complete.
- Around three months: return to heavier lifting and higher-impact exercise, as advised by your surgeon.
In terms of results, systematic reviews comparing uterine-preserving surgery with hysterectomy have generally found similar short-term anatomical success and satisfaction, with uterine preservation associated with shorter operating time and less blood loss in many studies. Long-term data, particularly beyond five years, are more limited. Recurrence can happen after any prolapse operation, and the front vaginal wall is a common site.
What are the main risks of each operation?
Both operations share the general risks of pelvic surgery: bleeding, infection, urinary retention, new or worsened bladder symptoms, pain during sex and recurrence of prolapse. Specific concerns include:
- Manchester repair: narrowing of the cervical canal, which can trap menstrual blood or make future cervical screening and endometrial sampling more difficult; possible cervical weakness in a later pregnancy.
- Sacrospinous hysteropexy: temporary buttock pain from nerve irritation, which usually settles within weeks.
- Laparoscopic sacrohysteropexy: risks linked to keyhole surgery and to mesh, including mesh exposure or erosion, though these appear less common with abdominal placement than with transvaginal mesh.
Because the uterus remains in place, ongoing gynecologic monitoring is still needed. Any postmenopausal bleeding should be investigated promptly.
Which should you choose?
There is no single best operation. The choice depends mostly on your anatomy and your priorities. As a general guide:
- A Manchester repair may suit you if your main problem is a long cervix, you want a purely vaginal operation without mesh, and you are not planning pregnancy.
- A vaginal sacrospinous or uterosacral hysteropexy may suit you if the whole uterus has descended, you want to keep the cervix, and you prefer to avoid both mesh and abdominal incisions.
- A laparoscopic sacrohysteropexy may suit younger, active women with more significant apical prolapse who accept a mesh implant in exchange for potentially stronger apical support.
Surgeon experience matters a great deal. Ask how many of each procedure your surgeon performs and which they would recommend for your examination findings, and why.
Frequently asked questions
Can I get pregnant after a Manchester repair or hysteropexy?
Pregnancy is possible after either operation, but it places strain on the repair and can cause prolapse to return. The Manchester repair may also affect the cervix during pregnancy. Most surgeons suggest delaying prolapse surgery until childbearing is complete if symptoms can be managed with a pessary or pelvic floor training.
Is hysterectomy more durable than keeping the uterus?
Current evidence does not clearly show that removing the uterus makes prolapse repair more durable in suitable women. Reviews suggest broadly comparable outcomes, but long-term data are still being collected. The quality of apical support matters more than whether the uterus is removed.
Will I still have periods after these operations?
Yes. Because the uterus and its lining remain, periods continue until menopause. In rare cases after a Manchester repair, cervical narrowing can make periods painful or blocked, which needs medical attention.
Is mesh used in hysteropexy?
Only in sacrohysteropexy, where mesh is placed through the abdomen. Vaginal sacrospinous and uterosacral hysteropexy use stitches and your own tissue. Transvaginal mesh for prolapse has been withdrawn from the US market since 2019.
Do I need tests before uterus-sparing surgery?
Usually yes. A cervical screening test, assessment of any abnormal bleeding and sometimes a pelvic ultrasound are recommended to confirm the uterus is healthy before deciding to keep it.
References
- American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and American Urogynecologic Society. Practice Bulletin No. 214: Pelvic Organ Prolapse. Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2019.
- Meriwether KV, et al. Uterine preservation vs hysterectomy in pelvic organ prolapse surgery: a systematic review with meta-analysis and clinical practice guidelines. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2018.
- Maher C, et al. Surgery for women with apical vaginal prolapse. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2016.
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Urinary incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse in women: management (NG123), 2019.
- US Food and Drug Administration. FDA takes action to protect women's health, orders manufacturers of surgical mesh intended for transvaginal repair of pelvic organ prolapse to stop selling all devices, 2019.
This article is for general education and does not replace an examination by a qualified gynecologist. Individual results vary, and every procedure carries risks.









